As global tariffs drive up the price of raw materials, many organizations are rethinking their locker material choices. Historically, metal has been the go-to option for locker rooms, athletic facilities, and commercial spaces—but with rising costs and long-term maintenance concerns, is it still the best investment?
That’s why we’re breaking down your options with a clear comparison of Metal, Laminate, and Phenolic lockers—so you can make a smarter, more sustainable choice for your next project.

Durability: Who Stands Stronger?
- Metal: Prone to scratching, denting, and rust, metal lockers often don’t hold up well under heavy use or in moisture-rich environments.
- Laminate: A much more resilient choice, laminate is resistant to scratches, dents, and rust—perfect for high-traffic areas.
- Phenolic: The top performer in durability. Highly resistant to water, UV rays, and scratches, plus it’s anti-microbial, making it ideal for wellness, healthcare, and high-humidity environments.
Winner: Phenolic (for superior durability in tough environments)
Best Value: Laminate (great durability with cost-conscious appeal)
Customization: Match Your Brand
- Metal: Offers limited customization, often restricted to basic colors and finishes.
- Laminate: Highly customizable with a vast selection of finishes, colors, and textures to suit any aesthetic or brand identity.
- Phenolic: Equally highly customizable, with refined finishes and design versatility.
Winner: Laminate & Phenolic (both allow you to elevate your space with design-driven options)
Maintenance: Simplify Your Routine
- Metal: Requires frequent maintenance, especially if exposed to wear or humidity.
- Laminate: Low-maintenance and easy to clean—just wipe down to remove spills or smudges. Plus, individual doors or panels are easy to replace if needed.
- Phenolic: The ultimate in low maintenance. Easiest to clean and care for, with minimal upkeep required over time.
Winner: Phenolic (effortless maintenance = peace of mind)
Cost: Long-Term Value Matters
- Metal: While the initial price may be lower, costs add up quickly with repairs, replacements, and upkeep.
- Laminate: A cost-effective choice that balances affordability and durability—especially smart for long-term use.
- Phenolic: Comes at a higher initial investment, but pays off in durability and long-term savings.
Best Budget Balance: Laminate
Premium Investment: Phenolic
Environmental Impact: Choose Sustainability
- Metal: Least eco-friendly, with a higher environmental footprint in production and disposal.
- Laminate: Made from pre-consumer recycled content, laminate lockers are a sustainable option without sacrificing performance.
- Phenolic: Also eco-friendly, crafted with recycled materials to support greener building initiatives.
Winner: Laminate & Phenolic (ideal for environmentally conscious projects)
The Smarter Choice Starts Here
With material prices on the rise and expectations for durability, design, and sustainability higher than ever, it’s time to explore locker solutions that work smarter, harder, and longer.
Laminate and phenolic lockers offer the modern features today’s facilities demand—from lower maintenance and greater customization to a smaller environmental footprint and better long-term value.
Whether you’re outfitting a training facility, employee break room, gym, or spa, Hollman’s laminate and phenolic solutions provide a future-ready alternative that elevates the user experience—and protects your investment.
Ready to upgrade? Contact our team today
Visit our website at Hollman.com
Discover Hollman Lockers

EXPLORE ESSENTIALS COLLECTION
The essentials collection consists of Hollman’s most popular configurations, models, and materials curated together to cut lead times, guaranteeing your lockers delivered between 4-6 weeks upon order approval.

EXPLORE WORKSPACES
When a workspace needs to put in overtime, Hollman leverages 40+ years of manufacturing expertise to transform traditional spaces into innovative environments with lockers that add agility.

DISCOVER SMART LOCKERS
With Hollman’s Smart Lockers each locker can be configured to the needs of every working zone in your building with a variety of configurations, materials, and the security solution that allows you to assign temporary or mixed-used.